Before you compare softeners, it helps to confirm that hard water is actually causing the trouble in your home. Several everyday signs point that way, and a few of them can be checked in an afternoon.
What hard water leaves behind
Hard water carries dissolved minerals, mostly calcium and magnesium. When the water heats or dries on a surface, those minerals stay behind as a chalky or crusty deposit. Over time the deposit builds up in places where water sits or evaporates.
Look at the fixtures
Check the faucet aerators, the showerhead face, and the rim of a kettle. White or chalky crust in those spots is a common sign. Unscrew one aerator and soak it in vinegar for a while. If the crust comes off and returns within weeks, the water is the likely cause. If the crust sits on one fixture only, the cause may be local, so check the others before you decide.
Look at the dishes and laundry
Glassware that comes out of the dishwasher with a cloudy film or white spots points to mineral deposits. Towels and clothes that feel stiff after washing, or soap that lathers poorly and leaves a film on the skin of the tub, are other clues. Notice whether these signs appear across the whole house or only at one tap.
Look at the water heater
Scale builds up inside a water heater tank. A popping or rumbling sound while the tank heats is one sign of sediment. If you have a drain valve on the tank, you can draw off a small amount of water and look for grit or flakes. Ask a qualified plumber to inspect the tank if you see either sign.
Before you shop
Ask your water supplier for the water quality report it publishes, and see whether hardness is listed for your area. Then ask any provider which hardness measurement they used in their assessment and what unit it was reported in. If the signs above appear across the house and the supplier's figures are high, a softener is worth comparing. If the signs are limited to one fixture, fix that first and watch whether the problem comes back.