When a provider tells you which system you need, that answer is built on a set of measurements about your water. If you do not know what those measurements were, you cannot judge whether the system fits your home. Before you accept a recommendation, ask to see the data it came from. This takes a few minutes, and it protects you from paying for a unit sized to the wrong problem.
Ask where the sample came from
A reading is only useful if it describes the water that reaches your fixtures. Ask the provider where the sample was taken. The ideal answer is a tap inside your home, ideally the cold kitchen tap or the closest point to where the new equipment would sit. A sample taken at an outdoor spigot, a neighbor's house, or a utility report for the general area may describe something different from what you actually use. Ask whether any equipment was already on the line when the sample was taken, because a softener, filter, or cartridge upstream can change the numbers.
Ask which measurements were taken, and in what units
Look at the list of things measured. For a typical home decision, the common ones are hardness, iron, manganese, pH, and chlorine, though your provider may test for different things depending on what you described. Each number needs a unit. A hardness figure with no unit, or a note that says only 'high' or 'moderate', is not enough to compare against a product specification. Ask the provider to write the units next to each value so you can check them against the spec sheet for any system they propose.
Ask whether the test was a lab report or a strip reading
Strip tests and lab reports are both useful, but they answer different questions. A strip gives a quick, rough picture. A lab report gives a precise number for each measured item. If the recommendation rests on a strip reading, ask whether the provider plans to confirm the key numbers before the order is placed. You do not need to send a sample out yourself to ask this question. You only need to know which kind of result the decision is based on.
Check that the numbers match what you see
Compare the reading with what you already notice in the house. Spots on glassware, a crust around faucets, or staining in the sink are signs of certain conditions, and cloudy or gritty water points to others. If the test says one thing and your fixtures show another, ask why. Sometimes the answer is that the sample was taken at a different time or place. Sometimes the test missed something. Either way, you want that gap explained before you pay. Our methodology page describes how we match systems to the conditions a household reports, and it is a useful reference for what a sound match looks like.
Ask what would change the recommendation
A good provider can tell you which numbers drive the choice. Ask which measurement, if it were different, would lead them to recommend a different system or a different size. This question shows you whether the recommendation is tied to real data or to a standard package. If the provider cannot name the deciding numbers, you have learned something about how the recommendation was built.
Ask for the reading in writing
Once you have the numbers, ask that they be copied into the quote or attached to it. Keep a copy with your home records. If the system does not perform as expected later, the original reading is what anyone will need to look at, whether that is you, the provider, or a plumber you hire later. Written numbers also make it easier to compare two providers who tested the same water in different ways.
When to walk away
Be cautious if a provider names a system before any test, if the reading has no source or units, or if the only explanation for the recommendation is that it is what they usually install. You are not expected to be a water chemist. You are expected to ask for the evidence behind a decision that will sit on your plumbing for years, and a provider who can show that evidence clearly is usually one you can work with.